Monroe County Florida

Code Compliance Details

CODE COMPLIANCE DETAIL
Case Number CE20090114
Case Date 09-28-2020
Origination 5 -REFERRAL Status CLOSED CASE
Operator grantc Officer GRANT, CHRISTOPHER
PROPERTY ON CASE
Parcel ID 00479170000000 Owner SUMMIT TAVERNIER LLC
Unit Owner Address 4521 PGA BLVD STE 403
Property Address 200 FLORIDA AVE City/State/Zip PALM BEACH GARDENS , FL 33418-3997
City/State/Zip KEY LARGO , FL 33037
CASE DESCRIPTION
FAILURE TO CONNECT TO THE CENTRAL SEWER SYSTEM.
ART. III SEC 20-51.(A)
VIOLATION CODES
1: 20-51.(a) - MANDATORY CONNECTION/SEWER
INSPECTIONS / EVENTS DETAILS
DATE INSPECTION/EVENT TYPE INSTRUCTIONS/COMMENTS
09-01-2022 CLOSE CASE EVENT

09-01-2022 CLOSE CASE EVENT

CASE CLOSED, PASSED FILE TO ADMIN FOR

SCANNING. CG

09-01-2022 COMMENT CODE

LIEN RELEASE RECORDED AT DOC# 2390032,

BK# 3192, PG# 1220. CG

08-18-2022 COMMENT CODE

DRAFTED LIEN RELEASE FOR SIGNATURE. CG

08-18-2022 CURRENT FILE LOCATION

ORIGINAL FILE GIVEN TO COLLECTIONS

FACILITATOR. NP

08-18-2022 PAYMENT RECEIVED

CHECK IN THE AMOUNT OF 4544.61 REC'D FOR

PAYMENT OF FINES AND COSTS. RECEIPT NO.

02000066517. NP

FINE PAYMENT: 20-51.(A)

PAYMENT DATE: 08/18/2022

PAYMENT AMOUNT: $4,050.00

COSTS PAYMENT

PAYMENT DATE: 08/18/2022

PAYMENT AMOUNT: $494.61

COPY OF RECEIPT IN ORIGIANL FILE AND

COPY EMAILED TO COLLECTIONS FACILITATOR.

NP

08-18-2022 COMMENT CODE

FINE SETTLED 20-51.(A)

SETTLE DT: 08/11/22 SETTLE AMT: 4050.00

08-11-2022 MITIGATION OF FINES OFFER

EMAILED REDUCTION OFFER TO THE LAW FIRM

OF SMITH/HAWKS. OFFER TO REMAIN OPEN AND

VALID FOR 30 DAYS:

"...THE COUNTY WILL ACCEPT $4,544.61

($4,050.00 FINES AND $494.61 COSTS) AND

PROVIDE A FULL SATISFACTION AND RELEASE

OF LIEN..."

CG

08-04-2022 COMMENT CODE

REVIEW COMPLETE, FORWARDED TO ACA. CG

07-11-2022 COMMENT CODE

RECEIVED REQUEST ON 7/8/22 TO REVISIT

FINES. CG

06-29-2022 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

EMAILED COPY OF FINES AND COSTS LETTER

TO ATTY. LUCAS STYLE LANASA OF

SMITH/HAWKS - MROD

06-13-2022 COMMENT CODE

RECEIVED DOH ABANDONMENT FORM SIGNED AND

DATED JUNE 3,2022.

VERIFIED WITH KLWTD THAT THE PROPERTY IS

NOW CONNECTED AND ABANDONED.

THIS PROPERTY IS COMPLIANT ON MCC

20-51.A AS OF 6/3/2022,

FORWARDING COMPLIANCE EVIDENCE FOR

REVIEW. CG

06-09-2022 LETTER NON-PAYMENT/COMPLIANCE

FINES AND COSTS LETTER MAILED TO PO;

ALSO EMAILED COPY TO ATTY. JEFFREY P.

LEARY OF SMITH/HAWKS

...THE CURRENT AMOUNT OF THE MONROE

COUNTY LIEN IS $16,644.21 ($16,200.00

FINES AND $444.21 COSTS... - MROD

06-09-2022 CURRENT FILE LOCATION

ORIGINAL FILE IN COMPLIANT DRAWER - MROD

06-07-2022 ACTIVITY BY SR DIRECTOR

RECEIVED CONFIRMATION DATED 6-2-22 FROM

DOH. PO ATTESTS TANK ABANDONED IN 2014

AS PART OF CONSTRUCTION OF POOL AREA.

PLUMBING INSPECTOR STATES ALL LINES ARE

CAPPED OFF. POOL AREA CONNECTED AS PART

OF 2014 PERMIT. AREA AROUND POOL

CONFIRMED TO BE CONNECTED TO SEWER, AREA

FILLED WITH SUITABLE SOIL. NO SANITARY

NUISANCE OBSERVED AT TIME OF VISIT.

COMPLIANCE EVIDENCE FORWARDED TO

RESEARCH ANALYST. CJM

20.51 (A) COMPLIANT 6-2-22.

06-07-2022 COMMENT CODE

IN COMPLIANCE 20-51.(A)

COMPLIANCE DATE WAS : 06/02/22

06-01-2022 COMMENT CODE

EMAILED DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH ON 5/27/22.

REPLY FROM DOH INDICATED THEY ARE STILL

WAITING ON THE APPLICATION FROM SUMMIT

TAVERNIER. CG

04-28-2022 COMMENT CODE

A SITE VISIT BY KEY LARGO BUILDING

DEPARTMENT PLUMBING INSPECTOR REVEALED A

LIFT STATION UNDER THE STAIRS OF ONE OF

THE TWO BUILDING ON EITHER SIDE OF THE

BOAT RAMP. THE VISIT ALSO INDICATED BOTH

BUILDINGS, WERE NOT CONNECTED.

THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH WILL BE SENDING

AN ENGINEER TO PROVIDE INSIGHT ON THE

REMAINING ISSUES. CG

04-22-2022 COMMENT CODE

RECEIVED EMAIL THROUGH DIRECTOR

MCPHERSON FROM SMITH/HAWKS INDICATING

THE OWNER BELIEVES THE CONNECTION

STANDARD HAS BEEN MET BY A DEMO OF THE

PREVIOUS SYSTEM AND OR CAPPING OFF OTHER

PRE-EXISTING LINES.

EMAILED PLUMBING INSPECTOR IN KEY LARGO

REQUESTING A SITE VISIT TO DETERMINE IF

ALL STRUCTURES WERE ADDRESSED AND

PERMITTED. CG

04-13-2022 COMMENT CODE

EMAILED PLUMBING INSPECTOR IN KEY LARGO

FOR INFORMATION ON THIS PROPERTY. CG

04-06-2022 REINSPECTION

90-DAY REI

DEMO PERMIT 21302254 PASSED FINAL

PLUMBING ON 4/6/22 AND IS STILL OPEN.

UNABLE TO DETERMINE AT THIS TIME IF ALL

BUILDINGS ARE CONNECTED. CG

03-23-2022 COMMENT CODE

MAILED 75 DAY LETTER. CG

03-22-2022 REINSPECTION

75-DAY REI: NOT COMPLIANT AT THIS TIME.

MCESEARCH SHOWS DOH ABANDONMENT TURNED

IN 2/14/22.

DEMO PERMIT 21302254 REMAINS OPEN WITH

NO FINAL PLUMBING/FINAL DEMO

INSPECTIONS.

CONNECTION OF ALL APPLICABLE STRUCTURES

TO BE DETERMINED BY KEY LARGO BUILDING

DEPARTMENT.

CG

02-23-2022 PERMIT APPLICATION REVIEW

REVIEWED REVISION A TO DEMO PERMIT

21302254. 30 X 30 BUILDING TO REMAIN.

REMOVAL/DEMO OF PLUMBING ONLY. CJM

02-17-2022 ACTIVITY BY SR DIRECTOR

REC'D CALL FROM ATTY LEARY OF

SMITH/HAWK. REVIEWED PERMITS AND

REMAINING ITEMS TO GAIN COMPLIANCE. CJM

01-21-2022 COMMENT CODE

PHONE CALL FROM ATTORNEY JEFFERY P.

LEARY OF SMITH HAWKS.

EXPLAINED THE FOLLOWING:

TO DATE, ONLY THE BATH HOUSE IS

CONNECTED UNDER PERMIT 14304970 WHICH

DOES NOT ADDRESS ANY REMAINING

STRUCTURES/SERVICES.

PROPERLY CLOSING SEWER TIE IN PERMIT

18301038 SHOULD SATISFY HOW ANY

REMAINING STRUCTURES/SERVICES ARE

CONNECTED: (SALES/SERVICE BUILDING,

OFFICE/STORE/BAR, LAUNDRY FACILITIES

ETC.)

SEWER TIE IN PERMIT 18301038 AND DEMO

PERMIT 21302254 REMAIN OPEN WITH NO

INSPECTIONS.

IF THE DEMO PERMIT IS TO SATISFY

ABANDONMENT PER MCC 20-51.(A), THE

ABANDONMENT LETTER FROM DEP/DOH/KLWTD

SHOULD BE SUBMITTED TO BOTH PERMITS.

CG

01-20-2022 ACTIVITY BY SR DIRECTOR

REC'D EMAIL FROM MANAGER INQUIRING WHAT

CASE CLOSURE. REPLIED REVIEW SHOWS DEMO

PERMIT REMAINS OPEN WITH NO INSPECTIONS

AND WAITING COORDINATION LETTERS FOR

ULITLTY/DOH/DEP. CJM

01-11-2022 COMMENT CODE

LIEN LETTER MAILED TO PROPERTY OWNER VIA

1ST CLASS US MAIL ON 01/11/22. NP

01-06-2022 LIEN ORDER RECORDED MCCO

LIEN/FINAL ORDER RECORDED ON 01/06/22

DOC # 2356000. BOOK 3147 PAGES

1716-1721. NP

01-04-2022 ORDER SENT TO MCCO FOR REC

FINAL ORDER AND STIP SENT TO CLERK'S

OFFICE FOR RECORDING. NON-COMPLIANT. NP

12-21-2021 REINSPECTION

AN EMAIL WAS RECEIVED ON DECEMBER 10,

2021 FROM T ATLANTIC BAY CONSTRUCTION,

INC. WHO AS THE CONTRACTOR ON A DEMO

PERMIT, REQUESTED ADDITIONAL TIME TO

COMPLY FOR THE PROPERTY OWNER. EMAIL

FORWARDED TO DIRECTOR AND ACA FOR REVIEW

AS THE PERMIT DOES NOT SPECIFICALLY

ADDRESS THE REMAINING BUILDINGS AND HOW

THEY ARE CONNECTED TO THE CENTRAL SEWER.

PER THE ACA, AN EXTENSIVE AMOUNT OF TIME

HAS ALREADY BEEN GIVEN WITHOUT PROGRESS,

NO EXTENSION WILL BE GRANTED.

IT IS RECOMMENDED THE OWNER AND

CONTRACTOR COORDINATE WITH DOH/DEP/KLWTD

AND THE MONROE COUNTY BUILDING

DEPARTMENT TO ENSURE ALL CONNECTIONS TO

ANY AND ALL BUILDINGS WITH SERVICE ARE

CONNECTED UNDER A COUNTY PERMIT WITH ALL

APPROVALS, PASSING FINAL INSPECTIONS AND

ARE CLOSED.

ADDITIONALLY, SEWER TIE IN PERMIT

18301038 REMAINS OPEN WITH NO

INSPECTIONS.

PROPERTY IS NOT COMPLIANT. CG

12-10-2021 COMMENT CODE

CLARIFICATION: A DEMO PERMIT MAY

PARTIALLY SATISFY THIS CASE IF

DOH/DEP/KLWTD CONCUR AS PART OF THE

ABANDONMENT.

HOWEVER, A SEWER CONNECTION IS STILL

REQUIRED PER KLWTD. CG

11-17-2021 PERMIT APPLICATION REVIEW

REVIEWED PERMIT 21302254 FOR THE

DEMOLITION OF A BUILDING:

PERMIT 21302254 MAY PARTIALLY SATISFY

CODE CASE CE20090114.

THIS IS A REFERRAL FROM KLWTD AND A

CURRENT MEMO HAS BEEN ADDED TO THE

PERMIT FILE AS THERE SEVERAL STRUCTURES

REMAINING.

PLUMBING PERMIT 18301038 REMAINS OPEN

WITH NO INSPECTIONS FOR RE#

00479170000000

A MONROE COUNTY PERMIT TO CONNECT OR A

PERMIT TO DISCONNECT BY DEMOLITION IS

REQUIRED WHICH MAY REQUIRE DEP/DOH

COORDINATION.

PERMITS REQUIRE ALL APPROVALS, ALL FINAL

INSPECTIONS AND MUST BE CLOSED.

CG

06-25-2021 COMMENT CODE

COPY OF FINAL ORDER AND STIP AGREEMENT

MAILED TO PROPERTY OWNER VIA 1ST CLASS

US MAIL BY LIAISON ON 06/25/21. NP

06-25-2021 COMMENT CODE

ADDED FINE ON 20-51.(A)

START DATE: 12/22/21

FINE AMT:$100.00

06-25-2021 SM OR CEB ORDER

LIEN/FINAL ORDER SIGNED ON 06/25/21 AS A

RESULT OF THE HEARING HELD ON 06/24/2021

STIPULATION AGREEMENT SIGNED ON 06/21/21

BY ROBERT CHARNEY ON BEHALF OF SUMMIT

TAVERNIER LLC COSTS IMPOSED UNTIL

COMPLIANT AND CASE IS CLOSED AND FINES

IN THE AMOUNT OF $100.00 FOR THE CHARGES

OF 20-51.(A). PER DAY PER IF NOT

COMPLIANT BY 12/21/2021 . NO REVIEW

HEARING SET AT THIS TIME.

NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER WAS NOT PRESENT AT

HEARING VIA ZOOM.

06-24-2021 INSPECTORS HEARING NOTES

OWNER NOT PRESENT, STIPULATED AGREEMENT.

A DAILY FINE OF $100.00 TO RUN IF NOT

COMPLIANT BY 12/21/2021. CG

06-24-2021 SET FOR HEARING

06-22-2021 COMMENT CODE

PASSED STIP TO LIAISON FOLDER. CG

06-21-2021 COMMENT CODE

EMAILED STIPULATED AGREEMENT TO OWNER.

CG

06-16-2021 REINSPECTION FOR HEARING

SEWER TIE IN PERMIT 18301038 REMAINS

OPEN, PROPERTY NOT COMPLIANT. CG

06-15-2021 COMMENT CODE

DRAFTED STIPULATED AGREEMENT FOR

APPROVAL. CG

06-07-2021 COMMENT CODE

EMAIL REPLY TO

SARAN@MANGROVEMARINA.COM'S REQUEST FOR 9

MONTH EXTENSION:

"...I CAN OFFER TAVERNIER LLC A

STIPULATED AGREEMENT OF 180 DAYS FROM

THE DATE OF THE HEARING..."

"...IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO PURSUE A

STIPULATED AGREEMENT JUST LET ME KNOW

AND I’LL DRAFT ONE...."

CG

06-04-2021 COMMENT CODE

REC'D REQUEST FOR EXTENSION AND

ATTACHMENTS FROM PROPERTY OWNER ROBERT

CHARNEY VIA EMAIL ON 06/02/21 (15

PAGES). FOWARDED TO COUNTY ATTY,

DIRECTOR AND CHRIS GRANT ON 06/04/21.

05-27-2021 ACTION BY ADMIN

ORIGINAL FILE AND COPY TO LIAISON FOR

HRG DATE 6/24/2021. SCANNED FILE INTO

LOCAL NETWORK FOR ACCESS TO EXHIBITS.

–LM-

05-27-2021 ACTION BY ADMIN

RECEIVED GOOD SERVICE FOR NOV/NOH FOR

6/24/2021 HRG. CERT#7018 0360 0002 1537

1343 -LM-

05-25-2021 COMMENT CODE

ROBERT CHARNEY CALLED TO EXPLAIN THE

ENGINEERING CHALLENGES ON THIS PROPERTY

AND ASK FOR A CONTINUANCE.

DIRECTED TO THE LIAISON. CG

05-20-2021 ACTION BY ADMIN

MAILED NOV/NOH TO PROPERTY OWNER VIA

CERT MAIL FOR HEARING DATE 6/24/2021.

CERT MAIL #7018 0360 0002 1537 1336.

-LM-

MAILED NOV/NOH TO PROPERTY OWNER VIA

CERT MAIL FOR HEARING DATE 6/24/2021.

CERT MAIL #7018 0360 0002 1537 1343.

-LM-

05-19-2021 ACTIVITY BY SR DIRECTOR

REVIEWED AND APPROVED NOV/NOH FOR SM

HEARING JUNE 24, 2021. CASE FILE

FORWARDED TO ADMIN. CJM

05-13-2021 COMMENT CODE

AMENDED NOV/NOH HEARING DATE TO JUNE 24,

2021. CG

04-15-2021 MAKE VIOLATION

PREPARING NOV/NOH FOR MAY 27, 2021 SM

HEARING. CG

04-15-2021 REINSPECTION

UPDATED REGISTERED AGENT IN FILE AND ZIP

CODE ERROR ON MAILING ADDRESS FOR

MANAGER. SEWER TIE IN PERMIT 18301038

REMAINS OPEN WITH ONLY A NOTICE OF

COMMENCEMENT RECORDED FEBRUARY 5, 2019;

PROPERTY NOT COMPLIANT. CG

10-19-2020 ACTION BY ADMIN

FIRST CLASS COURTESY NOTICE RETURNED

"VACANT-UNABLE TO FORWARD" UNDELIVERED

SERVICE -LM-

10-05-2020 COMMENT CODE

RETURNED CALL TO ATTY JOHN JABRO,

REGISTERED AGENT AND EXPLAINED THE SEWER

TIE IN PERMIT WAS STILL OPEN WITH NO

INSPECTIONS. CG

09-29-2020 POSTING OF NOV/NOH/MOTION/LTR

MAILED SEWER REFERRAL AND CONTACT

INFORMATION TO LLC AND REGISTERED AGENT.

POSTED REFERRAL AT PROPERTY. CG

09-28-2020 INITIAL INSPECTION TYPE

REFERRAL FROM KLWTD.

SEWER TIE IN PERMIT 18301038 ISSUED

7/10/2018 HAS ONLY A NOTICE OF

COMMENCEMENT AND NO OTHER INSPECTIONS.

09-28-2020 CREATE A CASE

VIOLATION RECORDED GRANTC