Monroe County Florida

Code Compliance Details

CODE COMPLIANCE DETAIL
Case Number CE19020073
Case Date 02-12-2019
Origination 1 -PHONE CALL Status CLOSED CASE
Operator shockf Officer BOELLARD, FRANCIE
PROPERTY ON CASE
Parcel ID 00482250000000 Owner KALUS ONDREJ AND KATELYN
Unit Owner Address 415 SPRINGWOOD DR
Property Address 176 HARBORVIEW DRIVE City/State/Zip CARMEL , IN 46032
City/State/Zip KEY LARGO , FL 33037
CASE DESCRIPTION
COMPLAINANT CALLED AND SAID MULTIPLE FAMILIES,
CARS, AND TRAFFIC AGAIN COMING INTO THE
NEIGHBORHOOD.
***
CASE IS COMPLIANT AND HAS BEEN APPEALED.
FINES AND SOME COSTS PAID, COSTS CONTINUE TO
ACCRUE.
**
COMPLAINT CODES
1: VACATION RENTAL
VIOLATION CODES
1: 134-1.(k)(1) - VACATION RENTAL & ADVERTISING
2: OTF - ONE TIME FINE IMPOSED
NOTES
02-14-2019 02:04:17 pm
PREVIOUSLY CITED UNDER CE18030110 & CE17070053
03-20-2019 09:17:04 am
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ATTORNEY FILED ON 03/20/19 BY:
JACK BRIDGES
FLORIDA BAR NO. 0175950
POST OFFICE BOX 1714
TAVERNIER, FLORIDA 33040-1714
(305) 664-9690
INSPECTIONS / EVENTS DETAILS
DATE INSPECTION/EVENT TYPE INSTRUCTIONS/COMMENTS
11-05-2021 CLOSE CASE EVENT

11-05-2021 CLOSE CASE EVENT

CASE CLOSED, PASSED FILE TO ADMIN FOR

SCANNING. CG

11-05-2021 COMMENT CODE

COPY OF RECORDED LIEN RELEASE MAILED TO

ATTY JACK BRIDGES VIA 1ST CLASS US MAIL

ON 11/05/21 BY LIAISON.

EMAILED TO COLLECTIONS FACILITATOR FOR

ORIGINAL FILE. NP

11-04-2021 COMMENT CODE

LIEN RELEASED ON 11/04/2021

BOOK 3135 PAGE 1731

10-29-2021 ACTION BY LIAISON

LIEN RELEASE SENT TO CLERK'S OFFICE FOR

RECORDING. NP

10-15-2021 COMMENT CODE

DRAFTED LIEN RELEASE FOR SIGNATURE. CG

08-31-2021 COMMENT CODE

COPY OF REFUND CHECK IN THE AMOUNT OF

15,000.00 REC'D FROM FINANCE DEPT THAT

WAS MAILED TO PROPERTY OWNERS (CHECK

#10091799 DATED 08/18/21). NP

07-28-2021 ACTION BY ADMIN

AGREED ORDER GRANTING REFUND TO

RESPONDENTS NOT DELIVERABLE AS

ADDRESSED-UNABLE TO FORWARD. PASSED ON

TO THE LIAISON. -LM-

07-13-2021 FIRST CLASS MAIL RETURNED

AGREED ORDER GRANTING REFUND WAS

RETURNED TO SENDER "NOT DELIVERABLE AS

ADDRESSED UNABLE TO FORWARD" USPS DATED

07/13/21. NP

07-09-2021 ACTION BY LIAISON

VACATE & CORRECTED AGREED ORDER EMAILED

TO ATTY JACK BRIDGES AND COUNTY ATTY'S

OFFICE AND COPIES MAILED TO PROPERTY

OWNERS VIA 1ST CLASS US MAIL ON

07/09/21.

COPIES ALSO PROVIDED TO NICOLE RHODES

WITH CLERK OF THE COURTS OFFICE FOR

PROCESSING OF REFUND. NP

07-09-2021 SM OR CEB ORDER

AGREED ORDER GRANTING REFUND TO

RESPONDENTS SIGNED BY THE SPECIAL

MAGISTRATE ON 07/09/21:

"...PER THE MAY 25, 2021 OPINION IN THE

SIXTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT CASE

19-AP-4-P, REGARDING AN APPEAL OF THE

FINAL ORDER ISSUED IN CODE ENFORCEMENT

CASE NO. CE18030110, IT IS

ORDERED AND ADJUDGED:

1. THAT PETITIONER MONROE COUNTY,

FLORIDA SHALL REFUND $15,000.00 THAT WAS

PREVIOUSLY PAID BY THE RESPONDENTS

ONDREJ KALUS AND KATELYN KALUS…."

PLEASE NOTE: AN ORDER OF SAME (ABOVE)

WAS PREVIOUSLY SIGNED BY THE SM ON

07/01/21 AND SUBSEQUENTLY VACATED ON

07/09/21 IN ORDER TO CORRECT THE CASE

NUMBER). NP

05-25-2021 COMMENT CODE

OPINION IN CASE NO.: 19-AP-04-P

CE19020073 ISSUED BY CIRCUIT COURT

JUDGE, TIMOTHY J. KOENIG ON 05/25/21:

"...THIS CAUSE COMES BEFORE THE COURT

UPON THE APPELLANTS' NOTICE OF APPEAL

FROM A CODE

ENFORCEMENT FINAL ORDER. THE COURT,

HAVING CONSIDERED THE APPELLANTS'

INITIAL BRIEF, THE APPELLEE'S

AMENDED ANSWER BRIEF, THE APPELLANTS'

REPLY BRIEF, THE EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT

OF COUNSEL AT THE

HEARING HELD BEFORE THIS COURT ON

FEBRUARY 5, 2021, PERTINENT LEGAL

AUTHORITY, AND BEING OTHERWISE

FULLY ADVISED IN THE PREMISES, FINDS AND

ORDERS AS FOLLOWS...

...FOR THE FOREGOING REASONS, THE FINAL

ORDER OF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE IS

AFFIRMED AS TO

THE FINDING OF VIOLATION AND REVERSED AS

TO THE IMPOSITION OF FINES. THE CASE IS

REMANDED

FOR THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE TO ENTER AN

AMENDED ORDER CONSISTENT WITH THIS

RULING...."

10-23-2020 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

APPEAL PENDING; CASE NO. 19-AP-4-P -

MROD

10-23-2020 CURRENT FILE LOCATION

ORIGINAL FILE IN COMPLIANT DRAWER - MROD

09-16-2019 REINSPECTION

08-30-2019 REINSPECTION

75-DAY REI (COSTS CONT TO ACCRUE APPEAL

FILED) BALANCE OWED $77.00

07-18-2019 CASE ON APPEAL

07-18-2019 CURRENT FILE LOCATION

ORIGINAL FILE IN LITIGATION FILE.

KW

05-16-2019 PAYMENT RECEIVED

CHECK IN THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF $30281.01

RECEIVED FOR PAYMENT OF COSTS AND FINES.

RECEIPT #02000052058. -NP-

COPY OF RECEIPT GIVEN TO SENIOR RESEARCH

ANALYST.

FINE PAYMENT: OTF

PAYMENT DATE: 05/16/2019

PAYMENT AMOUNT: $29,968.00

COSTS PAYMENT

PAYMENT DATE: 05/16/2019

PAYMENT AMOUNT: $313.01

05-16-2019 PAYMENT RECEIVED

FINE PAYMENT: OTF

PAYMENT DATE: 05/16/2019

PAYMENT AMOUNT: $30,000.00

COSTS PAYMENT

PAYMENT DATE: 05/16/2019

PAYMENT AMOUNT: $281.01

05-12-2019 CURRENT FILE LOCATION

ORIGINAL FILE LIENS MAY 2019

KW

05-06-2019 COMMENT CODE

LIEN LETTER MAILED TO PO VIA 1ST CLASS

US MAIL ON 05/06/19 BY LIAISON.NP

05-02-2019 LIEN ORDER RECORDED MCCO

SM FINAL ORDER RECORDED WITH CLERK'S

OFFICE ON 05/02/19 DOC 2218172 BOOK 2961

PAGES 2442-2443.NP

04-23-2019 CASE ON APPEAL

NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED BY JACK BRIDGES

ON 04/23/19 VIA FLORIDA E-FILE PORTAL.

NP

NOTICE OF FILILNG TRANSCRIPT FILED BY

JACK BRIDGES ON 04/23/19 VIA FLORIDA

E-FILE PORTAL

03-29-2019 COMMENT CODE

COSTS (281.01) & OTF (30000.00) INVOICE

MAILED TO PO AND ATTY JACK BRIDGES VIA

1ST CLASS MAIL (INVOICE WAS ENCLOSED

WITH MAILING OF FINAL ORDER AND WITH

COPY OF ORDER DENYING MOTION TO

DISQUALIFY) ON 03/29/19. NP

03-29-2019 SM OR CEB ORDER

ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISQUALIFY

ISSUED AND SIGNED BY THE SM ON 03/29/19.

03-29-2019 COMMENT CODE

ADDED FINE OTF

FINE AMT: 30000.00

03-29-2019 SM OR CEB ORDER

SM FINAL ORDER FOUND IN VIOLATION AS

CITED AS A REPEAT VIOLATOR FOR ONDREJ

KALUS AND KATELYN KALUS. COSTS IMPOSED

UNTIL COMPLIANT AND CASE IS CLOSED AND

THE CHARGE OF 134-1.(K)(1) WAS DEEMED

COMPLIANT. NO REVIEW HEARING SET AT THIS

TIME.

ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISQUALIFY WAS

ISSUED AND SIGNED BY THE SM UNDER A

SEPARATE ORDER.

ONE TIME FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $

30,000.00 ALSO IMPOSED AND PAYABLE

WITHIN 30-DAYS

NOTE: ATTORNEY, JACK BRIDGES WAS PRESENT

AT HEARING.

03-28-2019 SET FOR HEARING

03-28-2019 INSPECTORS HEARING NOTES

ATTORNEY BRIDGES WAS PRESENT - SPECIAL

MAGISTRATE FOUND THE PROPERTY OWNER IN

VIOLATION; WITH A ONE TIME-PENALTY OF

$15,000.00 FOR ADVERTISING, & A ONE TIME

PENALTY OF $15,000.00 FOR HOLD-OUTS,

PAYABLE IN 30 DAYS; PLUS ADMINISTRATIVE

COSTS - FB

03-28-2019 REINSPECTION

I CONDUCTED A GOOGLE SEARCH OF THE

PROPERTY & AD SLOGAN. I FOUND THEIR

HOMEAWAY/VRBO.COM LISTING #4233305 WERE

BOTH REMOVED FROM THE INTERNET. NO OTHER

ADVERTISEMENTS WERE FOUND OFFERING THE

PROPERTY AS A RENTAL.

I PASSED COMPLIANCE EVIDENCE TO LIAISON

(3-29-19)- FB

03-19-2019 COMMENT CODE

COMPLAINANT STATES NEW RENTERS WEEKLY -

SEEMS SOME ARE REPEAT GUESTS -

03-19-2019 COMMENT CODE

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ATTORNEY FILED

ON 03/19/19 VIA EMAIL BY JACK BRIDGES.

NP

ALSO FILED MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE.

03-18-2019 ACTIVITY BY SR DIRECTOR

REC'D CALL FROM CONCERNED NEIGHBOR ABOUT

REPEAT BEHAVIOR. ACTIVITY HAS NOT

STOPPED. CJM

03-01-2019 GOOD SERVICE ON CERT MAIL ITEM

RECEIVED GOOD SERVICE ON NOV/NOH CERT

#7018 0360 0002 9234 FOR HEARING

3/28/2019 - TM

02-14-2019 ACTION BY ADMIN

MAILED NOV/NOH VIA CERTIFIED TO PO

03/28/2019 HRG. CERT#:7018 0360 0002

1536 9234- FS

02-14-2019 NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING

PREPARED NOTICE OF VIOLATION FOR

3/28/2019 SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING -

FB

02-14-2019 MAKE VIOLATION

MAKEVIO RECORDED BOELLARD

02-12-2019 CREATE A CASE

COMPLAINT RECORDED

01-29-2019 VACATION RENTAL INSPECTION

VRI CONDUCTED - FB

01-25-2019 REINSPECTION

RESEARCH CONDUCTED - FS