Monroe County Florida

Code Compliance Details

CODE COMPLIANCE DETAIL
Case Number CE07050258
Case Date 05-25-2007
Origination 1 -PHONE CALL Status CLOSED CASE
Operator hatteryl Officer WINDSOR, KATHLEEN
PROPERTY ON CASE
Parcel ID 00489136012000 Owner MONTILLA MARLENE FONTIRROCHE
Unit Owner Address 9310 SW 137TH AVE APT 902
Property Address 174 NORMANDY DR BLUE WATER TRL City/State/Zip MIAMI , FL 33186-1406
City/State/Zip TAVERNIER , FL 33070
CASE DESCRIPTION
NO RAILINGS ON BACK EXTERIOR ELEVATED PORCH.
***
ORIGINAL INSP WAS INSP HATTERY.
***
CASE COMPLIANT 5/7/2009
VIOLATION CODES
1: 6-4(a)(c) - UNSAFE BUILDINGS & MAINTENANCE
NOTES
05-25-2007 04:04:47 pm
DID SITE VISIT AND TOOK PHOTOS. THERE IS
AN ELEVATED DECK AREA ON THE CANAL SIDE
OF THE PROPERTY THAT HAS NO RAILINGS.
UNSAFE. SENT UNSAFE MEMO TO JOE P.
06-13-2007 03:41:02 pm
RECEIVED SIGNED UNSAFE FROM BLDG.
OFFICIAL TODAY. SENDING OUT THE NOV.
07-16-2007 02:28:40 pm
POSTED BOTH NOV AND NOTICE OF HEARING AT
THE COURT HOUSE AND THE PROPERTY,
INSPECTIONS / EVENTS DETAILS
DATE INSPECTION/EVENT TYPE INSTRUCTIONS/COMMENTS
11-09-2016 CLOSE CASE EVENT

CLOSED CASE AND PASSED TO NICOLE FOR

SCANNING.

11-09-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

PREPARED LIEN RELEASE FOR SIGNATURE AND

MAILING.

11-09-2016 COMMENT CODE

FINE PAID 6-4(A)(C)

PAID DATE: 11/01/16 PAID AMT: *******

FINE SETTLED 6-4(A)(C)

SETTLE DT: 10/21/16 SETTLE AMT: *******

11-01-2016 PAYMENT RECEIVED

CHECK IN THE AMOUNT OF 21,200.00 REC'D

FOR PAYMENT OF FINES & COSTS PER SM

MITIGATION ORDER.

FINES: 21,100.00 COSTS: 100.00) RECEIPT

NO. 02000035410

COPY OF RECEIPT GIVEN TO SR. RESEARCH

ANALYST BY LIAISON.

10-29-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

FILE IN LITIGATION DRAWER

10-21-2016 SM OR CEB ORDER

SM ORDER IMPOSING FINE SIGNED AND DATED

10/21/16:

"...IT IS ORDERED THAT RESPONDENT IS

FINED A TOTAL OF $21,100.00 FOR THE

VIOLATION FOUND TO EXIST ON HER PROPERTY

IN THE ORDER DATED AUGUST 3, 2007. NO

LATER THAN 30 DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF

THIS ORDER, RESPONDENT SHALL PAY TO THE

COUNTY THE SUM OF $21,200.00 ($21,100.00

IN FINES AND $100.00 IN COSTS). FAILURE

TO PAY THIS SUM WITHIN THE TIME ALLOWED

SHALL RESULT IN THE RESTORATION OF THE

FULL, UNMITIGATED TOTAL FINE OF

$123,200.00 PLUS COSTS...."

10-21-2016 ACTION BY LIAISON

SM ORDER IMPOSING FINE EMAILED AND

MAILED VIA 1ST CLASS MAIL TO PO ON

10/21/16.

09-15-2016 SET FOR HEARING

SCHEDULED FOR MITIGATION REQUEST

09-15-2016 COMMENT CODE

MITIGATION HEARING HELD AND SM TO ISSUE

ORDER.

NOTE: MARLENE MONTILLA AND EDUARDO

MONTILLA WERE BOTH PRESENT AT HEARING

09-12-2016 ACTION BY LIAISON

LIAISON CALLED MR. MONTILLA TO INFORM

HIM THAT THE COUNTY'S PACKET WAS

PREPARED FOR THE SM FOR HEARING ON

09/15. SINCE HE DOES NOT HAVE EMAIL

ACCESS AND IT'S TOO LARGE TO EMAIL HE

INDICATED THAT WE CAN PROVIDE A PRINTED

COPY FOR HIM AT THE HEARING.

09-06-2016 COMMENT CODE

MR. MONTILLA CALLED LIAISON AGAIN AND

SAID HE DID NOT RECEIVE THE MITIGATION

FROM/REMINDER NOTICE MAILED TO THE NEW

ADDRESS ON 08/29. (CONFIRMED CORRECT

ADDRESS AS WRITTEN). FAXED TO PO TODAY.

CONFIRMATION 2 PAGES SENT ON 09/06/16.

08-29-2016 ACTION BY LIAISON

LIAISON REC'D PHONE CALL FROM EDUARDO

MONTILLA INFORMING ME THAT HE NO LONGER

HAS EMAIL ACCESS. HE GAVE ME ALTERNATE

MAILING ADDRESS TO RE-MAIL PRE

MITIGATION FORM AGAIN AND ALSO GAVE ME

HIS CELL # (IN ORIGINAL FILE FOR

REFERENCE).

08-18-2016 REMINDER NOTICE OF HRG SENT

REMINDER NOTICE OF HEARING FOR 09/15/16

WITH PREHEARING MITIGATION REQUEST FORM

ATTACHED MAILED TO PO VIA 1ST CLASS

MAIL. ALSO EMAILED TO EDUARDO MONTILLA

AT EMONTILLAMD@GMAIL.COM ON 08/18/16 BY

LIAISON.

08-15-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

EMAIL FROM PO HUSBAND SELECTING

9-15-2016 SM

08-12-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

RTE VM TO PO. WISHES TO APPEAR AT SM.

EMAILED AVAILABLE DATES.

08-11-2016 MITIGATION OF FINES OFFER

REQUEST LETTER REVIEWED BY SW. AS A

RESULT, MAILED REDUCTION OFFER TO PO AND

EMAILED TO REALTOR THAT IS INQUIRING:

THE COUNTY WILL ACCEPT, $61,878.70

($61,600.00 FINES AND $278.70 COSTS),

AND PROVIDE A FULL SATISFACTION AND

RELEASE OF LIEN. THIS OFFER IS GOOD FOR

30 DAYS.

08-10-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

RECEIVED EMAIL FROM REALTOR THAT THE

PROPERTY OWNERS MAILING ADDRESS HAS BEEN

CORRECTED.

PASSED REDUCTION REQUEST LETTER FROM

PO'S HUSBAND TO SW FOR CONSIDERATION

07-28-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

REPSONDED TO ANOTHER EMAIL FROM REALTOR

REGARDING REDUCTION.

RESEARCH REVEAL ADDRESS STILL NOT

CORRECTED.

MY RESPONSE:

THE COUNTY WILL CONSIDER A REDUCTION

AFTER THE MAILING ADDRESS FOR THE

PROPERTY OWNER IS CORRECTED. AS I

EXPLAINED IN MY TWO PREVIOUS EMAILS, IT

REMAINS:

MONTILLA MARLENE FONTIRROCHE

9350 SW 136TH ST

MIAMI, FL 33176

YOU MAY LET ME KNOW WHEN THAT HAS BEEN

COMPLETED.

07-11-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

RECEIVE EMAIL FROM REALTOR WITH LETTER

FROM PO REQUESTING REDUCTION, FURTHER

STATING THAT THEY SOLD THE PROPERTY AT

9350 SW 136, MIAMI IN 2004.

MY RESPONSE:

SINCE THIS CASE WAS APPROVED FOR

LITIGATION, BY WAY OF THIS EMAIL, I

HAVE

INCLUDED MR. WILLIAMS, OUR ASSISTANT

COUNTY ATTORNEY FOR CODE. HE WILL

REVIEW THE LETTER.

ADDITIONALLY, THE MAILING ADDRESS ON

THE

COUNTY TAX RECORDS REMAIN AS FOLLOWS:

MONTILLA MARLENE FONTIRROCHE

9350 SW 136TH ST

MIAMI, FL 33176

THIS ADDRESS CAN BE CHANGED AT EITHER

THE PROPERTY APPRAISERS OFFICE OR THE

TAX COLLECTOR’S OFFICE.

06-08-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

EMAIL TO REALTOR:

THIS CASE WAS THE RESULT OF THE FAILURE

TO PROVIDE SAFETY RAILINGS ON AN

EXTERIOR ELEVATED PORCH.

I HAVE REVIEWED THE FILE AS PROMISED,

AND IT IS VERY CLEAR THAT ALL ATTEMPTS

TO CONTACT THE PROPERTY OWNER REGARDING

THE LIEN HAVE FAILED. THERE WERE

SEVERAL POSTINGS AT THE PROPERTY DURING

THIS CASE AND THE ADDRESS ON THE TAX

RECORDS REMAINS:

9350 SW 136TH ST

MIAMI, FL 33176

A HEARING WAS HELD ON JULY 27, 2007 AND

THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOUND THE

PROPERTY IN VIOLATION AS CITED AND

IMPOSED A COMPLIANCE DATE OF AUGUST 23,

2007 WITH A REVIEW HEARING IF

COMPLIANCE

WAS NOT ACHIEVED BY THAT DATE. AT THE

HEARING ON AUGUST 30, 2007 THE SPECIAL

MAGISTRATE IMPOSED A DAILY FINE OF

200.00 BEGINNING ON AUGUST 30, 2007.

ANOTHER HEARING WAS HELD ON SEPTEMBER

27, 2007 AND THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE

IMPOSED THE LIEN.

ADDITIONALLY ANOTHER HEARING WAS HELD

ON

APRIL 24, 2008 AND THE SPECIAL

MAGISTRATE APPROVED A MOTION TO PROCEED

WITH COLLECTION ACTIONS. THIS CASE WAS

THEN APPROVED BY THE BOCC (BOARD OF

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS) FOR LITIGATION ON

AUGUST 20, 2008.

I CANNOT EXPLAIN WHY LITIGATION NEVER

COMMENCED, BUT MY RESEARCH REVEALED

THAT

THE PERMIT FOR THE CORRECTIVE ACTIONS

WAS CLOSED ON MAY 7, 2009, THEREBY

ACHIEVING COMPLIANCE.

THEREFORE THE 200.00 DAILY FINE ACCRUED

FOR 616 DAYS (AUGUST 30, 2007 – MAY 7,

2009) FOR A FINE TOTAL OF $123,000.00.

THE COSTS TO DATE ARE 260.10 AND

CONTINUE TO ACCRUE UNTIL THE LIEN IS

PAID.

I HAVE ATTACHED THE TWO LETTERS THAT

WERE MAILED IN AN ATTEMPT TO RESOLVE

THIS ISSUE WITHOUT LITIGATION.

THE PAYOFF TODAY IS 123,260.10.

THE PROPERTY OWNER CAN RESOLVE THIS

MATTER BY REMITTING A CHECK OR MONEY

ORDER FOR PAYMENT IN FULL TO:

MONROE COUNTY CODE COMPLIANCE

DEPARTMENT

ATTENTION: NICOLE PETRICK

2798 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY, SUITE 330

MARATHON, FLORIDA 33050

THE COUNTY WILL THEN PROVIDE A RELEASE

AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN TO YOU. IT IS

THEN YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO RECORD THE

RELEASE AND SATISFACTION WITH THE CLERK

OF COURTS IN MONROE COUNTY.

AS I STATED IN OUR CONVERSATION, THE

COUNTY WILL REVIEW WRITTEN REQUESTS FOR

REDUCTIONS. THE REQUEST SHOULD INCLUDE

THE EXTENUATING CIRCUMSTANCES TO BE

CONSIDERED. PLEASE HAVE THE PROPERTY

OWNER EMAIL IT, OR MAIL IT TO THE

ADDRESS BELOW.

06-02-2016 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

RECEIVED PC FROM MARYANN WARREN,

REALTOR, ASKING FOR PAYOFF.

123,600.00

SHE IS GONIG TO SPEAK TO PO AND

POSSIBLY

EMAIL ME FOR DETAILS OF CASE.

EMAILED STEVE AND JACLYN THAT THIS CAME

UP.

ALSO ADDED TO MY SPREADSHEET OF BOCC

APPROVALS

08-03-2015 COMMENT CODE

ORIGINAL FILE IN COMPLIANT DRAWER

05-22-2013 LETTER NON-PAYMENT/COMPLIANCE

MAILED 14 DAY COLLECTION LTR FROM CA

05-06-2013 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

RESEARCH REVEALS THAT THE PROPERTY WHICH

IS THE MAILING ADDRESS FOR THE PO WAS

FORECLOSED ON AND PURCHASED WITH A

CERTIFICATE OF TITLE BY SK FL 9350 LLC.

THIS LLC DOES NOT APPEAR TO HAVE ANY

CONNECTION WITH THE MONTILLA'S.

CANNOT LOCATE ANY OTHER MAILING ADDRESS.

03-09-2012 COMMENT CODE

RECIEVED ORIGINAL FILE BACK FROM KW CA

OFFICE.

03-02-2012 LETTER NON-PAYMENT/COMPLIANCE

MAILED 30-DAY COURTESY LETTER.

200.00 RAN 616 DAYS = 123,200.00 FINES

COSTS TO DATE = 200.00

03-02-2012 COMMENT CODE

REVIEWED CASE.

MAILING ADDRESS FOR PO HAS REMAINED THE

SAME AND NO RECORD OF ANY RESPONSE FROM

PO IN FILE EXCEPT THAT

A PERMIT FOR CORRECTIONS WAS ISSUED AND

COMPLETED.

01-13-2011 COMMENT CODE

01-13-2011 COMMENT CODE

IN COMPLIANCE 6-4(A)(C)

COMPLIANCE DATE WAS : 05/07/09

01-13-2011 ACTION BY SR CC RES ANALYST

RESEARCH REVEALS THAT THIS FILE WAS

SENT

TO KW AND COLLECTION ACTIONS WERE

GRANTED 8-20-2008 BY BOCC.

NO LIS PENDENS BY COUNTY FOUND IN

CLERK'S WEB SITE.

ALSO RESEARCH REVEALS PERMIT 08303879

FOR

RAILINGS PASSED FINAL INSPECTION ON

05-07-2009.

EMAILED BRIAN TO CONFIRM PERMIT WAS FOR

THIS CASE - KAT.

01-13-2011 COMMENT CODE

KAT PULLED PERMIT SITE PLAN FOR

083-3879

AND RAILINGS ON SITE PLAN MATCH

DISCRIPTION OF VIOLATION ON EGOV

08-20-2008 CASE HEARD BEFORE BOCC

BOCC AUTHORIZED COLLECTION PROCEEDINGS

08-20-2008 SENT FILE TO COUNTY ATTY

BOCC GRANTED AUTHORIZATION TO INSTITUTE

COLLECTION PROCEEDINGS

04-24-2008 XXXELIGIBLE FOR FORECLOSURE

MOVED FORWARD FOR COLLECTIONS

04-24-2008 SM GRANTED MOTION TO PROCEED

MOTION GRANTED.

COPY OF ORDER MAILED TO PO 1ST CLASS

MAIL

04-23-2008 OFFICIAL FORM

AFFIDAVIT PRINTED BY CORCORAB

03-24-2008 MOTION BY COUNTY TO PROCEED

MOTION TO AUTHORIZE COLLECTION

PROCEEDINGS AND NOTICE OF HEARING MAILED

TO PO FOR HEARING TO BE HELD ON APRIL

24, 2008.

12-12-2007 LIEN ORDER RECORDED MCCO

ORDER FILED MCCO DOC 1674312 BK

2336 PD 221.

10-11-2007 POSTING OF NOV/NOH/MOTION/LTR

ORDER IMPOSING PENALTY/LIEN POSTED AT

SUBJECT PROPERTY AND COURTHOUSE AS WELL

AS MAILED 1ST CLASS MAIL.

09-27-2007 LIEN ORDER RECORDED MCCO

REVIEW HEARING HELD.

SM ORDERED THAT THE LIEN BE IMPOSED

09-24-2007 REINSPECTION FOR HEARING

NON COMP

09-21-2007 OFFICIAL FORM

AFFIDAVIT PRINTED BY CORCORAB

09-12-2007 POSTING OF NOV/NOH/MOTION/LTR

FINDING OF FACT/ORDER WAS POSTED AT

SUBJECT PROPERTY AND COURTHOUSE AS WELL

AS MAILED 1ST CLASS MAIL.

09-07-2007 COMMENT CODE

ADDED FINE ON 6-4(A)(C)

START DATE: 08/30/07 FINE AMT: 200.00

08-30-2007 XXXIMPOSITION OF PENALTY

HEARING HELD.

FINES IMPOSED AS OF 08/30/07 IN THE AMT

OF $200.00 PER DAY REVIEW ON 09/27/07

08-29-2007 REASSIGN INSPECTOR

REASSIGNED FM T KERR WHO RETIRED TO

B CORCORAN

08-05-2007 COMMENT CODE

SM ORDERED 100.00 COSTS

07-27-2007 XXXFINDING OF FACT

VIOLATION $100 ADMIN COSTS RES ON FINES

COMP. 08/23/07 HEARING 08/30/07

07-21-2007 UNCLAIMED CERT MAIL ITEM

MAIL ITEM RETURNED TO COUNTY UNCLAIMED,

UNABLE TO FORWARD.

07-20-2007 OFFICIAL FORM

AFFIDAVIT PRINTED BY TDKERR

07-13-2007 POSTING OF NOV/NOH/MOTION/LTR

NOV/NOH WAS POSTED AT SUBJECT PROPERTY

AND COURTHOUSE.

07-05-2007 NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING

NOV/NOH MAILED CERTIFIED MAIL FOR SM

7/27/2007.

06-14-2007 SENT TO DIRECTOR FOR REVIEW

SENT UNSAFE TO DIRECTOR FOR HEARING

REVIEW

06-14-2007 COMMENT CODE

PREPARE UNSAFE FOR SM/SENT TO ADMIN

06-13-2007 REINSPECTION

RECEIVED THE UNSAFE MEMO FROM BLDG.

OFFICIAL TODAY. SENDING UNSAFE TO K BASS

TO SEND OUT NOV

05-25-2007 INITIAL INSPECTION TYPE

UNSAFE - NO RAILINGS ON BACK ELEVATED

DECK.

05-25-2007 CREATE A CASE

VIOLATION RECORDED HATTERYL